Facebook
Back to blog Ohio Supreme Court ruling leaves some unmarried same-sex parents without a legal path
Two mothers and their child sharing a cozy moment on the sofa

Ohio Supreme Court ruling leaves some unmarried same-sex parents without a legal path

Profile Photo Daddy November 21, 2026

Ohio’s highest court has dealt a setback to same-sex parents who had children together before marriage equality. On April 28, 2026, the Supreme Court of Ohio ruled in In re L.E.S. that courts cannot retroactively decide whether a couple “would have been married” if Ohio had allowed same-sex marriage at the time, and then use that finding to grant parental rights.

What happened

The case involved two women who had children through donor insemination while they were together but unable to marry in Ohio. After they split, the non-biological mother asked to be recognized as a legal parent. She argued that Ohio’s artificial insemination law, which makes a husband the legal father of a child conceived this way, should apply to same-sex couples under Obergefell v. Hodges.

An appeals court agreed and told the trial court to decide whether the couple would have married but for Ohio’s ban. The Supreme Court reversed that decision. Writing for the court, Justice R. Patrick DeWine said married same-sex couples are entitled to the same benefits as opposite-sex couples, but the U.S. Supreme Court’s rulings do not require states to extend those benefits to couples who never married.

Why it matters

The ruling means that in Ohio, a non-biological parent from a pre-2015 unmarried same-sex relationship has no statutory path to parentage under the insemination law. Many LGBTQ families formed long before they had the option to marry, so the decision reaches beyond this one case.

Other states have gone the other way. Michigan’s Supreme Court ruled that unmarried LGBTQ parents who were barred from marrying can seek custody of children they raised with a former partner, saying children of same-sex partners have no lesser right to two parents.

What families can do

  • Don’t rely on marriage alone. Advocates recommend that non-biological parents get a court judgment, such as a confirmatory adoption or a parentage judgment, even when married. A court order is recognized everywhere; a presumption based on marriage may not be.
  • Check your state’s parentage laws. More than half of states still lack clear, equal pathways for LGBTQ parents to establish parentage, according to the Movement Advancement Project.
  • Talk to a family law attorney who works with LGBTQ families, especially if your children were born before you married.

Sources: Court News Ohio, State Court Report, Bridge Michigan, Movement Advancement Project.

This article is for information only and isn’t legal advice.

Share