They were once a couple who wanted a child. One donated the egg. The other had it implanted into her womb and carried the child to term. After they two broke up, a circuit judge ruled that the mom who bore the child is the mother. Last week, however, a state appeals court in Daytona Beach overturned his decision, saying the other mother has parental rights, too. The 5th District Court of Appeal ruled that the U.S. and Florida constitutions trump Florida law and give parenting rights to both women. Under Florida law, a woman who gives birth is the mother. State law, it added, has not kept up with the times.
Both lesbian moms have legal rights to child in Florida break up
Related Blogs
Florida’s new surrogacy restrictions: What intended parents need to know
A 2026 Florida law adds citizenship requirements to surrogacy, aimed at international intended parents. It took effect July 1 with no grandfather clause for pregnancies already underway.
Ohio Supreme Court ruling leaves some unmarried same-sex parents without a legal path
Ohio’s top court ruled unanimously that judges can’t ask whether a same-sex couple “would have married” before 2015 to decide parentage. Here’s what it means for families.
New year, new protections: 15 states now offer parentage forms to LGBTQ+ parents
As of January 1, 2026, parents of any gender or marital status can use a free voluntary acknowledgment of parentage in 15 states. Here’s what that form does and whether your state is on the list.
The Senate just passed historic protections for same-sex marriage
The Senate passed historic federal protections for same-sex marriage, sending a powerful message about the progress the country has made
Ricky Martin wants to normalize our families
Ricky Martin appeared on a recent episode of Ellen and he spoke about being a proud gay man who is
Florida’s Parent’s Bill of Rights may have fatal consequences for LGBTQ youth
A bill some fear will compel teachers and counselors to forcibly out LGBTQ students to their families is passing through
Pope Francis does the bare minimum
Pope Francis told a group of parents of LGBTQ children last week that God “loves your children as they are” and that
Streisand to Trump: Enough Is Enough
Barbra Streisand and Donna Summer’s song “Enough Is Enough” has been used in a super PAC-sponsored music video that blasts
Dads win battle with Trump over their family
Adiel and Roee Kiviti, the married couple that sued the State Department over their child’s citizenship, got an early Father’s Day