Parents of transgender kids in Los Angeles scored a significant privacy win this month. The U.S. Justice Department has agreed to drop its demand for records that would have identified thousands of young patients of Children’s Hospital Los Angeles (CHLA), after families went to court to stop it.
What the government wanted
According to CalMatters and the Associated Press, the subpoena was one of more than 20 sent to providers last summer. It sought intake forms, insurance claims and documents sufficient to identify patients who had been prescribed puberty blockers or hormones, including names, dates of birth, addresses and parent or guardian information. The department said it was investigating health care fraud and false statements. Lawyers for the families said it never provided evidence of fraud and called the effort a fishing expedition.
How families fought back
Seven families whose children received care at CHLA sued in November to quash the subpoena. Their lawyers, from Lawyers for Good Government, the Western Center on Law & Poverty and the Impact Fund, argued that it violated patients’ constitutional privacy rights and exceeded the government’s authority. Under a settlement filed in federal court last Thursday, the Justice Department will withdraw its requests for documents identifying patients or families through 2029, and the plaintiffs have moved to dismiss the case. The hospital never turned over the records.
The same week, a judge in Baltimore rejected a similar request for records from Children’s National Hospital in Washington, D.C., CalMatters reports.
What families can do
- Ask your child’s care team for its written policy on responding to subpoenas and records requests.
- Keep your own copies of your child’s medical records and insurance paperwork.
- If a hospital or insurer tells you your records have been requested by a government agency, contact a civil rights or health privacy attorney promptly.
- Connect with other parents; the CHLA families’ story shows how much a group of ordinary parents can accomplish together.
The settlement protects CHLA’s patients, not every family nationwide. Other hospitals have faced similar subpoenas that are being challenged in separate cases, so it’s worth staying informed about your own provider.
Sources: CalMatters; Impact Fund. This article is for information only and isn’t legal advice.
